Cervical screening in Canada, 2023-24

HPV testing

On this page:

Human Papillomavirus (HPV) testing is increasingly being recognized as the leading approach in cervical screening. The link between the persistent presence of HPV and the risk of developing cervical cancer has been established, making HPV primary screening advantageous as it identifies cervical pre-cancer earlier, resulting in a significantly lower likelihood of cervical cancer compared with Pap test screening. Learn more about HPV testing in Canada and the current state of the Elimination of Cervical Cancer.

One jurisdiction is currently using HPV testing as the primary screening method for cervical cancer. Eight provinces and two territories have plans to implement HPV testing for primary screening. Jurisdictions are currently undergoing activities to support the implementation of HPV primary screening, including developing guidelines and business and operation plans.

Status of HPV primary screening implementation

P/T  No current HPV primary screening activities Planning for implementation Piloting Partially implemented  Jurisdiction-wide implemented Plans to implement self-sampling to facilitate HPV primary screening implementation
YT
NT
NU
BC ✓* ✓*
AB ✓ (preparing business case)
SK
MB
ON ✓^
QC
NB ✓* ✓~
NS
PE ✓ Implemented change in May 2023
NL

*BC: Self-screening is available province wide for eligible people. During BC’s 3-year transition, LBC samples will be triaged to either primary cytology or HPV, depending on the patient’s age. Not all samples will have HPV testing, but HPV testing is available through self-screening for those who choose that collection method.
^ON: Ontario plans to implement self-sampling for HPV testing in a phased approach which will enable the program to determine how best to implement self-sampling in the Ontario context (e.g., designing the best clinical pathways to ensure follow-up of positive test results and optimizing kit distribution and return processes).
~NB: As of March 2023, approval to proceed with the implementation of the phased-in transition from cytology based testing (Pap) to HPV primary screening, with an option for self-sampling.

Definitions

Levels of implementation status (to show incremental implementation progress by jurisdiction):

  1. No current HPV primary screening activities: “Status Quo” cervical screening activities.
  2. Planning for implementation: Conducting environmental scanning, gathering requirements to determine approach for implementation (i.e., preparing/submitting business cases, forming advisory committees) and/or planning for pilots/programs for HPV primary screening and/or self-sampling.
  3. Piloting: Pilot has been implemented to offer HPV primary screening. Pilots include time-bound screening activities that do not have confirmed sustainable funding.
  4. Partially implemented: Organized HPV primary screening has rolled out in certain sites or for certain populations across the jurisdiction. Partial implementation includes organized screening being phased-in over a time by gradually increasing capacity of screening sites or if plans are in place to implement organized screening at additional site locations. Partial implementation has secured sustained funding to offer long-term organized screening.
  5. Jurisdiction-wide implemented: A fully implemented organized HPV primary screening program, which is available jurisdiction-wide, with or without options for self-sampling and embeds a culturally safe approach to care. Note: An organized program would include elements such as eligibility criteria, quality assurance mechanisms, participant recall, abnormal follow-up, etc.

Activities to support the transition to HPV primary screening

Ten jurisdictions are working towards the transition to HPV primary screening. Activities to support the transition include developing business cases, updating existing infrastructure, developing recommendations and pathways, and implementing pilot programs.

P/T Description of activities to support the transition to HPV primary screening
YT Updating infrastructure to support implementation of program
NT Planning is underway for pilot
NU
BC Transition to HPV primary screening completed as of January 2024*
AB
  • Planning for self-sampling pilot underway
  • HPV Test of Cure to support capacity in colposcopy
  • Business case development underway
  • IT infrastructure development to support test orders
SK
  • Data modelling (OncoSim) to assess human and financial resource impacts, and propose business cases
  • Initial high-level planning to identify and assess steps needed for shift to HPV primary screening
  • HPV self-sampling research study conducted by the University of Saskatchewan with assistance from the SPCC
  • Updating software to support implementation
  • Implementing HPV reflex triage system in 2023
MB
ON
  • Developing the future state cervical screening and colposcopy recommendations based on literature reviews, environmental scans, Ontario data analyses, and input from an international expert panel that includes public representatives
  • Planning a stakeholder engagement and communication strategy to support providers (providers performing screening and colposcopy) and public change management
  • Working with regional cancer programs to support the regional implementation of the HPV test (e.g., preparing to strike regional implementation steering committees)
  • Planning for required changes to program infrastructure to support HPV test implementation (e.g., updating correspondence mailing campaigns)
  • Developing recommendations with Ontario’s Ministry of Health for updates to the physician and laboratory fee schedules to reflect the future state program
  • Preparing request for proposal materials for the procurement of laboratory services and the HPV test system platform
QC
  • The Institut national d’excellence en santé et services sociaux (INESSS) has been commissioned to propose a screening pathway for cervical cancer using HPV as a primary test (documents expected summer 2023)
  • A transition plan will be issued by INESSS (summer 2023) to support clinicians in transitioning from Pap to HPV for primary test.
  • The cervical cancer screening and investigation committee of clinical experts in this field has been put in place to advise, assist, and make recommendations to the Ministry of Health and Social Services (MSSS), particularly regarding the implementation of incoming INESSS recommendations
  • Laboratory expert committee to restructure labs in order to implement HPV as a primary test and liquid-based cytology.
NB
  • Business case for the implementation of HPV primary screening, including an option for self-testing, was submitted and approved in March 2023
  • Planning is actively underway. Work towards the implementation of LBC province-wide is in alignment with Department of Health’s current Provincial Lab Reorganization project
NS
  • Updating infrastructure and preparing business case to support implementation
PE
  • Transition to HPV primary screening completed as of May 2023^
NL
  • Work underway to include development of a business and operation plan
  • Work will involve stakeholder engagement, working group, and consultation
  • Work underway to consider required Information management system components to accommodate the transition

*BC: BC is considering the following self-sampling and lab assays: Copan FLOQSwabs®, eluded into PreservCyt, COBAS instrument.
^PE: PE is considering the following self-sampling and lab assays: Self-vaginal FLOQSwabs® with breakpoint (COPAN HPC146R03 Date 2021.01 — product description), and BD Onclarity™ HPV Assay.
-NU, MB: No information was provided at the time data were collected.



Current uses of HPV testing
Six provinces and two territories are using HPV testing in triage, with most specifying it is used in participants ≥30 years old with ASC-US. Some jurisdictions use HPV testing in post treatment, while others are researching its use for triage within their jurisdiction.

Current capacity in which HPV testing is being used

P/T Capacity in which HPV testing is being used
YT Post treatment
NT Triage in participants
NU Triage in participants ≥30 with ASC-US
BC Post treatment and ASC-H follow-up
AB Triage in participants ≥30 with ASC-US or participants ≥50 with LSIL; posttreatment exit test
SK Healthcare providers can order an HPV test (i.e., non-reflexively) via requisition. Planning to implement HPV reflex testing for triage for clients ≥30 years of age with ASC-US and clients ≥50 years of age with LSIL in 2023
MB HPV triage implemented in February 2022. Initiative supports individuals ≥30 with an ASC-US cytology result, and individuals ≥50 with a LSIL cytology result
ON HPV testing is not currently funded by the Ontario Ministry of Health. However, it is available on a patient pay basis or in some hospital settings. Recognizing that it is available, the OSCP provides guidance to healthcare providers on when to consider its use (e.g., for people with a first time ASCUS result over age 30 or to discharge eligible patients from colposcopy).
QC Triage in participants ≥30 with ASC-US
NB Triage in participants ≥30 with ASC-US or participants ≥50 with LSIL
NS Colposcopy clinic
PE Triage in participants ≥30 with ASC-US and no previous abnormal Pap
HPV testing provided upon request by PCP or gynecologist as a 12-month follow-up test in treatment phase to confirm persistent or cleared HPV infection
HPV testing as primary screening tool
HPV testing provided as a follow-up test to confirm persistent or cleared HPV infection
NL Triage in participants ≥30 with ASC-US

Use of HPV testing after an abnormal cervical screening test result

P/T Pap primary screening with HPV triage/ reflex testing When Pap primary screening with HPV triage/reflex testing is used HPV with Pap Triage When HPV with Pap Triage is used Does HPV testing include HPV genotyping? When HPV with genetic triage is used
YT To be determined
NT One-year follow-up for LSIL or ASC-US for 21-29 years
ASC-US ≥30 years
LSIL or ASC-US post-menopausal
NU Pap with HPV reflect testing for participants ≥30 years with ASCUS
BC
AB Pap with HPV reflex testing for participants with ASC-US ≥30 and LSIL ≥50 To be determined To be determined
SK ✓ (2023) Planning to implement Pap with HPV reflex testing for participants with ASC-US ≥30 and LSIL ≥50 in 2023
MB Pap with HPV reflex testing for participants with ASC-US ≥30 and LSIL ≥50 Yes, HPV is reported in 16, 18, and ‘other’
ON ✓* HPV testing is not currently funded by the Ontario Ministry of Health. However, it is available on a patient pay basis or in some hospital settings. Recognizing that it is available, the OCSP provides guidance to healthcare providers on when to consider its use (e.g., for people with a first time ASCUS result over age 30 or to discharge eligible patients from colposcopy). ✓^
QC
After an abnormal Pap test screening, oncogenic HPV testing is used for participants ≥30 before following up with colposcopy, if HPV test is positive
NB Recommended as triage for participants aged ≥30 with an ASC-US or ≥50 with LSIL N/A N/A
Includes HPV genotyping
Triage for participants aged ≥30 with an ASC-US or ≥50 with LSIL

Some colposcopists may order ad hoc HPV test for cure post-colposcopy/treatment

NS
PE
Implemented HPV testing as primary screen, May 2023
Triage in participants ≥30 with ASC-US and no previous abnormal Pap.

Further HPV testing on request by PCP for treatment/exit management (e.g., repeat testing at 12 months to confirm persistent or cleared HPV infection)

Implemented HPV testing as primary screen in May 2023

Yes HPV-positive for other high-risk subtypes, not 16, 18, 45 Triage in participants ≥30 with ASC-US and no previous abnormal Pap

Further HPV testing on request by PCP for treatment/exit management (e.g., repeat testing at 12 months to confirm persistent or cleared HPV infection)

Implemented HPV testing as primary screen in May 2023

NL Triage in participants ≥30 with ASC-US

ON: * While in use in some cases, cytology screening alone is the current screening test recommended by the program. HPV testing with cytology triage is currently under development as part of planning for the implementation of HPV testing in Ontario.

Abbreviations:

  • ASC-US: atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance
  • LSIL: low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion
  • HSIL: high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion